GeForce GTX 580 vs Radeon HD 5870

How much faster is one than the other? Average frame rates across a 19-game suite at ultra settings, plus ray tracing, value, power and specs. Updated November 2026.

Ultra settings, native resolution, no upscaling or frame generation
+10%

GTX 580 is 10% faster than HD 5870 at 1440p

Overall gaming score, blending rasterized games with ray tracing.

FPS per $: HD 5870 +19%FPS per watt: HD 5870 +18%
NVIDIA · Fermi · Desktop

GTX 580est.

Launch price
$499
VRAM
1.5 GB
Power
244 W
Released
Nov 2010
3overall score at 1440p
(RTX 5090 = 100)
Get it on Amazon
AMD · TeraScale 2 · Desktop

HD 5870est.

Launch price
$379
VRAM
1 GB
Power
188 W
Released
Sep 2009
3overall score at 1440p
(RTX 5090 = 100)
Get it on Amazon

Amazon buttons are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Gaming performance

Average frame rate across a suite of current games. The percentage is how much faster the leading GPU is.

Rasterized avg FPS

1080p
8
7
1440p
5
5
4K
2
2

Ray tracing

GTX 580 and HD 5870 have no hardware ray tracing support.

GTX 580 and HD 5870 have 8 GB or less of video memory. Expect frame rates to drop sharply at 4K and with ray tracing, where newer games need more.
GTX 580 can't start many games released since 2023: it lacks the DirectX 12 features they need or has too little video memory. Its figures show relative speed, estimated from its compute power and how its architecture performs.
HD 5870 can't start many games released since 2023: it lacks the DirectX 12 features they need or has too little video memory. Its figures show relative speed, estimated from its compute power and how its architecture performs.

Verdict: GTX 580 is faster

The GTX 580 is 10% faster than the HD 5870 overall at 1440p. In rasterized games at ultra settings it averages 5 FPS against 5 FPS.

At launch prices ($499 and $379), the HD 5870 gives 19% more frames per dollar. Street prices change often, so check current deals.

The HD 5870 is the more efficient card, with 18% more performance per watt (rated 244 W vs 188 W).

Choose the GTX 580 if you need the extra speed; the HD 5870 makes sense if the saving matters more.

Watch them tested

Benchmark videos of the GTX 580 and HD 5870 running real games.

Video 1Benchmark video coming soon
Video 2Benchmark video coming soon
Video 3Benchmark video coming soon
Videos for this matchup are on the way. Until then, you can find tests on YouTube.Search YouTube: GTX 580 vs HD 5870

Value and efficiency

Based on 1440p rasterized frame rates.

Frames per $100 at launch price
1.1FPS / $1001.3
HD 5870 is 19% better
Frames per 100 W of board power
2.2FPS / 100 W2.6
HD 5870 is 18% better
Speed kept with ray tracing on
–% of raster FPS–
Needs hardware ray tracing on both

Specifications

▲ marks the better figure where higher (or, for power and price, lower) is clearly better. Shader counts and clocks are not comparable between brands or generations.

SpecGTX 580HD 5870
TypeDesktopDesktop
ArchitectureFermiTeraScale 2
GPU chipGF110Cypress
Shaders5121,600
Boost clock0.77 GHz0.85 GHz
VRAM1.5 GB1 GB
Memory typeGDDR5GDDR5
Memory bus384-bit256-bit
Bandwidth192 GB/s154 GB/s
Power244 W188 W
Launch price$499$379
ReleasedNov 2010Sep 2009
Ray tracingNoNo

Questions people ask

Is the GTX 580 better than the HD 5870?

Yes. The GTX 580 is 10% faster overall at 1440p, averaging 5 FPS vs 5 FPS in rasterized games.

How do the GTX 580 and HD 5870 compare at 1080p and 4K?

At 1080p: GTX 580 8 FPS, HD 5870 7 FPS (GTX 580 +8.1%). At 4K: 2 vs 2 FPS (GTX 580 +9.5%).

Which uses less power?

The HD 5870, rated at 188 W against 244 W.

Which has more video memory?

The GTX 580, with 1.5 GB against 1 GB.

Related comparisons

All GPUs ranked

Overall score (RTX 5090 = 100) at 1440p.

1 RTX 5090
100
2 RTX 4090
86
3 RTX 5080
76
5 RTX 4080
70
8 RX 9070 XT
66
10 RX 7900 XT
58
11 RX 9070
58
12 RTX 3090 Ti
58
13 RTX 4070 Ti
58
14 RTX 5070
56
15 RTX 3090
53